NJ Coin Shop | Buy and Sell Coins Across Central New Jersey

A real coin shop, not just a gold buyer

Most "we buy gold" shops treat coins like scrap. They weigh everything, multiply by spot, and hand you an offer.

That works fine for bent chains and broken earrings. It does not work for a 1921-S Morgan in AU condition or a tube of silver Eagles bought when spot was far lower.

We run a coin shop. That means we know the difference between bullion pricing and collector pricing, and we apply each one where it belongs.

We buy Morgan dollars, Peace dollars, gold Eagles, silver rounds, 90% junk silver, proof sets, slabbed coins, foreign gold, and full estate collections. We also sell bullion and coins to collectors and investors who walk in looking to buy.

That two-way flow is what separates a coin shop from a gold buyer with a coin sign in the window.

Why we are expanding while others close

Independent coin shops across New Jersey have been closing for years. The owners retire, the lease goes up, or the next generation is not interested. That leaves gaps in towns that used to have a local coin dealer.

We are filling those gaps. Nine stores, family-owned, all run by people who actually know coins. When a longtime collector in Middlesex, Monmouth or Ocean County needs a place to sell a collection or pick up bullion, we are the local option that did not disappear.

What we buy and sell

On the buy side: Morgan dollars, Peace dollars, American Gold Eagles, American Silver Eagles, Canadian Maple Leafs, Krugerrands, 90% silver quarters, dimes, and half dollars, silver bars, silver rounds, proof sets, mint sets, slabbed and graded coins, pre-1933 U.S. gold, foreign gold coins, and full estate collections.

On the sell side: We carry bullion, silver Eagles, gold Eagles, and select collector pieces depending on current inventory. Walk in or call ahead to ask what is in stock.

NJ coin dealers and New Jersey coin shops: eight in Central NJ

Cash 4 Gold Trading Post runs nine coin shops in Central New Jersey: Middlesex, East Brunswick and New Brunswick in Middlesex County, Millstone, Manalapan, Aberdeen and Farmingdale in Monmouth County, and Brick in Ocean County. Each one buys, sells and trades coins and bullion, and pays the same day.

Pick the store closest to you. Every location handles coins the same way: metal value and collector value separated, fair pricing, same-day cash.

Which NJ coin shop is closest to me?

Coming from Somerset County, Bound Brook, Piscataway or Dunellen, the Middlesex coin shop on Bound Brook Road is the short drive. From Edison, Old Bridge or Spotswood, use the East Brunswick coin shop on Main Street. In New Brunswick, Highland Park or Franklin Township, the New Brunswick coin shop on Bayard Street is closest. From Millburn, Summit, Mountainside or Union, the Springfield coin shop on Mountain Avenue is closest. From Hightstown, East Windsor, Allentown or Jackson, the Millstone coin shop on Monmouth Road (Route 537) is closest. From Freehold, Marlboro or Englishtown, the Manalapan coin shop on Route 9 is the one to visit. On the Bayshore (Matawan, Hazlet, Keyport), head to the Aberdeen store on Route 34. From Howell, Wall Township or Colts Neck, the Farmingdale store on Main Street is the short drive, and from Toms River, Point Pleasant or Lakewood, use the Brick store on Cedar Bridge Avenue.

Coin stores open today: which NJ coin shops are open now?

On a weekday all nine of our coin stores are open today from 10 AM to 6 PM, no appointment needed, so you can walk in with a single coin or a full collection. On Saturday every store is open except Brick and New Brunswick, and Saturday closing times vary by store, so check the store page or call before a late Saturday trip. All nine are closed Sunday except Manalapan, which is open Sunday 10am to 4pm.

Numismatic dealer near me: who knows collector coins in Central NJ?

All nine of our coin shops are staffed by buyers who look at a coin numismatically before they look at its metal: date, mint mark, variety, grade and eye appeal, checked against current collector pricing, so a key date or a scarce variety is never quoted as melt. We buy and sell US and world coins, certified slabs, proof and mint sets and bullion, and appraise a single coin or a whole collection free while you watch. Pick the closest store on this page and walk in, no appointment needed.

Metal value vs. collector value

This is the thing most gold buyers get wrong. A 1922 Peace dollar in average condition is worth its silver weight.

A 1921 Peace dollar in the same condition is worth significantly more because of scarcity. If you do not know the difference, you cannot price coins correctly.

We know the difference. Every coin that comes across the counter gets evaluated on its own terms.

Bullion gets bullion pricing. Better dates and higher grades get collector pricing.

Slabbed coins are evaluated by the slab, not weighed like scrap.

That is what a coin shop does. That is what we do at every one of our coin shops.

What is the melt floor on common coins today?

Every coin has a floor: the value of the metal inside it at the live spot price. A collector coin can be worth far more, never less. Here is that floor for the coins NJ sellers bring us most, worked out from the live market feed.

We quote the floor and the collector value side by side, so you see which one we are paying on. Selling a whole inherited collection? Start with how we buy a coin collection.