Sell Silver for Cash in New Jersey - Cash 4 Gold
Sterling silver, silverware, coins, jewelry — we buy it all at top market prices.
Why Sell Silver to Cash 4 Gold?
Real-Time Market Prices
We pay based on live silver spot prices. When silver is up, your payout is up.
We Beat Competitors
Got a quote elsewhere? Bring it in. We'll match or beat any legitimate offer.
Accurate Weighing
Certified scales and transparent weighing process. See exactly what you're getting paid for.
All Silver Welcome
Tarnished, damaged, or pristine — silver is silver. Condition doesn't affect melt value.
Understanding Silver Value
Types of Silver We Buy
- Sterling Silver (.925) — Jewelry, flatware, tea sets. Stamped "925" or "Sterling"
- Fine Silver (.999) — Bullion bars, some coins. Highest purity
- Coin Silver (.900) — Pre-1965 US coins (dimes, quarters, half dollars)
- Silver Plate — We can evaluate; some pieces have value
Why Silver Has Real Value
Silver is a precious metal used in jewelry, electronics, solar panels, and medicine. Unlike costume jewelry that's worthless when broken, silver always retains its metal value regardless of condition.
What to Bring
- ✓ Sterling silver jewelry (rings, chains, bracelets)
- ✓ Flatware sets (forks, knives, spoons)
- ✓ Tea sets, trays, candlesticks
- ✓ Silver coins (US and foreign)
- ✓ Silver bullion bars and rounds
- ✓ Scrap silver in any condition
Pro Tip: Check Your Kitchen
Many people have inherited silverware sitting unused. That old flatware set from grandma could be worth $500-$2,000+ depending on weight and pattern. We'll tell you in minutes.
What Determines Your Silver Payout
Silver pricing has some quirks that catch people off guard. Here's how we calculate it:
Purity — The Make-or-Break Factor
Sterling silver (.925) is 92.5% pure silver and pays real money. Silver plate is a base metal dipped in a thin silver coating — there's almost no silver to recover and payout is minimal. This is the single biggest variable we see catch people by surprise.
Weight in Troy Ounces
Silver is priced per troy ounce (31.1g). A heavy sterling flatware set can easily weigh 500+ grams — that's over 16 troy ounces of silver. Weight matters a lot here, which is why flatware and tea sets often surprise people with their value.
Tarnish Does Not Reduce Value
Black, patchy, oxidized — it doesn't matter. Tarnish is a surface reaction that does nothing to the silver underneath. We don't discount for tarnish. Don't bother polishing before you come in; it wastes your time and the weight difference is negligible.
Sterling vs. Silver Plate — Know the Difference
Look for "925," "Sterling," or "STERLING" stamped on the piece. Silver plate is often marked "EPNS," "Silver Plate," "Sheffield," or just has no mark. Pieces with hollow handles on flatware are almost always plated. We'll identify everything for you at no charge.
Coin silver note: Pre-1965 US dimes, quarters, half dollars, and dollar coins are 90% silver. They're worth significantly more than face value based on their silver content alone — a 90% silver quarter contains about 0.18 troy oz of silver.
Common Silver Selling Scenarios
What to expect when you walk in with your silver:
Inherited a Box of Old Silver Flatware?
This happens constantly. You clear out a house and find a case of silverware — maybe a full service for 12, maybe just a partial set that's been in a drawer for decades. Before you assume it's plated, check the backs of a few pieces for "Sterling" or "925." Genuine sterling flatware sets can weigh 800-1,500 grams total, which at current silver prices puts them in the $400-$900 range for melt value. We'll weigh the whole set, separate sterling from plate on the spot, and make you an offer in under 15 minutes.
Found a Jar of Old Coins in the Attic?
Pre-1965 US coins are 90% silver — dimes, quarters, half dollars, and Peace/Morgan dollars. The silver in a single pre-1965 quarter is worth roughly $5-$6 at current spot prices, nearly 25x face value. If you've got a jar or roll of old coins mixed in with regular change, bring them in and we'll sort through everything. The key date is 1964 — anything dated 1964 or earlier in dimes, quarters, and halves is almost certainly silver.
Sterling Silver Jewelry You Never Wear Anymore
Sterling silver jewelry is marked .925 or "Sterling" — usually inside a ring band or on the clasp of a necklace. Chunky sterling pieces, wide cuff bracelets, and heavy chains can weigh 20-50 grams each, which adds up fast. Unlike gold, silver jewelry value is almost entirely about weight and purity — the design doesn't affect the payout. Bring the pieces that are just sitting in your drawer and turn them into cash you'll actually use.
Silver Questions — Answered
What people ask us before they walk in the door:
How can I tell if my silver is sterling or just silver plate?
Check for a "925," "Sterling," or "STERLING" hallmark, usually stamped on the back or inside a piece. Silver plate is often marked "EPNS" (Electroplated Nickel Silver), "Silver Plate," or has no mark at all. Flatware with hollow or weighted handles is almost always plated. If you're not sure, bring it in — we test everything for free and tell you exactly what you have before making any offer.
Does tarnish lower what you pay for silver?
Not one penny. Tarnish (silver sulfide) is a thin surface layer that has zero impact on the silver content underneath. We pay for metal, not appearance. Don't spend time polishing before you come in — it doesn't change what we pay and just costs you effort. Black, spotted, completely oxidized — all pays the same as shiny.
Does the pattern or maker affect what flatware is worth?
For melt value, no — a Gorham pattern and a Reed & Barton pattern of the same weight pay the same. Where pattern matters is if you have a highly collectible set in excellent condition — some patterns have collector premium above melt. We'll let you know if that applies to what you have. But for the typical inherited flatware set, weight and purity are what matters.
Do you buy pre-1965 silver coins?
Yes, and we pay based on silver content — not face value. Pre-1965 dimes, quarters, half dollars, and silver dollar coins (Morgan, Peace) are 90% silver. We also buy silver Eagles, silver rounds, and generic silver bullion. If you have a mix of coins you're not sure about, bring them all — we'll identify which ones are silver and which are clad copies.
What's the difference between sterling silver and coin silver?
Sterling is 92.5% silver (.925). Coin silver — used in American coins before 1965 and in some early American flatware — is 90% silver (.900). The difference in payout is small since they're close in purity, but it's a distinction worth knowing. Coin silver flatware from the 1800s is sometimes marked "Coin" or "C" on the piece.
How much is a full sterling silver flatware set worth?
It depends entirely on weight. A typical service for 8 in sterling (around 40 pieces) might weigh anywhere from 600 to 1,200 grams. At current silver spot prices, that puts melt value in the $350-$700+ range for a standard set, potentially more for heavy or complete services for 12. The only way to know for sure is to weigh it — which we'll do free of charge when you come in.
Sell Silver at Any of Our 6 New Jersey Locations
Bring your sterling silver, coins, flatware, or bullion to any Cash 4 Gold Trading Post for a free appraisal.
Every location buys silver: sterling jewelry, flatware, coins, and bullion. Free testing and instant cash payment at all stores. Serving East Brunswick, Middlesex, Millstone, New Brunswick, Brick, Manalapan, and surrounding Central New Jersey communities.
💰 Get Your Free Silver Quote
Free appraisal, no obligation. We respond within minutes.