Coin Shop in New Brunswick, NJ
We buy gold coins, silver coins, bullion, 90% silver, Morgan dollars, and estate collections. Bullion gets priced off live spot. Collector coins get evaluated individually.
New Brunswick's coin shop on Bayard Street
Our New Brunswick store is at 51 Bayard Street, near the train station and downtown. We see coin sellers from New Brunswick, Highland Park, Edison, Franklin Township, Somerset, and the wider Middlesex County area.
New Brunswick draws a college-town mix. We get Rutgers families settling estates, longtime residents who collected for decades, and younger sellers who inherited coins and want a quick, honest evaluation. All of it works here.
The difference between us and a pawn shop is how we handle coins. We do not weigh everything and quote a flat per-gram price. Morgan dollars get evaluated by date, mint mark, and condition. Pre-1965 quarters get priced on silver content. Slabbed coins get looked up. Each piece gets what it deserves.
What we buy in New Brunswick
Gold coins: American Eagles (all sizes), Maple Leafs, Krugerrands, pre-1933 U.S. gold (Saints, Liberty heads, Indian heads), foreign gold coins, fractional gold.
Silver coins: Morgan dollars, Peace dollars, American Silver Eagles, 90% silver (pre-1965 dimes, quarters, halves), 40% Kennedy halves, junk silver bags, silver rounds.
Bullion: Silver bars (1 oz, 10 oz, 100 oz, kilo), gold bars, rounds from major mints. Priced off live spot.
Collections and estate lots: Coin albums, folders, proof sets, mint sets, rolls, safe-deposit-box contents. Bring it as-is and we sort it.
Collector and rare coins: Key dates, better-date series, PCGS and NGC slabbed coins. Graded coins get looked up, not weighed.
Metal value vs. collector value
Most coin sellers have a mix. Some pieces are worth melt. Others carry collector premiums that multiply the value. We separate the two categories before making an offer, and you see the breakdown before deciding.
If you have a bag of 90% silver quarters, those get priced on silver weight. If there is a 1932-S Washington quarter sitting in that bag, it comes out and gets evaluated as a collector coin. You see exactly how the number breaks down.
How it works
1. Walk in. Monday through Friday, 10am to 6pm. Saturday, 10am to 5pm. 51 Bayard St, New Brunswick. No appointment needed.
2. We evaluate. We sort by type, identify collector pieces, and build the offer around real values for each category.
3. You choose. Cash on the spot if you sell. No obligation if you want to think it over.
Get Your New Brunswick Coin Quote
Best for bullion, 90% silver, Morgan dollars, gold coins, and inherited collections. Walk-ins welcome at 51 Bayard St.