Millstone Coin Shop | Cash 4 Gold Trading Post

A coin shop in Monmouth County that knows coins

Western Monmouth County does not have many coin shops left. The ones that were here either closed or moved. Our Millstone location at 494 Monmouth Road fills that gap with a real coin dealer who can tell you whether your coin is worth melt or more.

We see collectors and estate sellers from Freehold, Manalapan, Monroe, Cranbury, Jamesburg, and across the Route 33 corridor. Some drive past two or three "we buy gold" shops to get here because they know we actually understand coins.

What we buy

Morgan dollars, Peace dollars, American Gold Eagles, American Silver Eagles, Canadian Maple Leafs, Krugerrands, 90% silver quarters, dimes, and half dollars, silver bars, silver rounds, proof sets, mint sets, slabbed and graded coins, pre-1933 U.S. gold, foreign gold coins, estate collections, and coin lots of any size.

We get a lot of estate visits at this location. Someone finds three albums, a cigar box of silver, and a few gold coins in a parent's closet. We go through the whole lot, pull out the pieces that deserve premium treatment, and price everything correctly.

What we sell

Silver Eagles, Gold Eagles, silver bars, silver rounds, and select collector pieces from recent acquisitions. Inventory rotates, so call (732) 444-2022 if you are looking for something specific.

Metal value vs. collector value

A roll of 90% silver Washington quarters is worth its silver content. A roll of Standing Liberty quarters from the same era might be worth more because of collector demand. We know the difference and we price accordingly.

Slabbed coins get evaluated by grade and rarity, not weighed on a scale. Proof sets get checked for key dates. Gold coins get checked for numismatic premium above melt. That is what a coin shop does that a generic buyer cannot.

1. Bring your coins in as-is. Albums, tubes, flips, slabs, loose bags, envelopes. Do not clean anything.

2. We sort and evaluate. Bullion goes in one pile, collector pieces in another. Each gets priced by the right method.

3. Review the offer. Same-day cash if you sell. No pressure if you want to think about it.