Sell Coins for Cash on Bayard St, New Brunswick NJ

New Brunswick's Downtown Coin Buyer

Our Bayard St store sits right in the heart of New Brunswick. It's one of the most accessible spots in Central Jersey, with Route 1 and Route 27 feeding right into town. If you've got coins to sell, getting to us is easy from Highland Park, Somerset, Franklin, North Brunswick, or Piscataway.

We buy coins from all backgrounds. New Brunswick is one of the most diverse communities in the state, and that means we see coins from all over the world. Mexican pesos with real silver content. British sovereigns. South African Krugerrands. Canadian Maple Leafs. Old European coins that have been in families for generations. If your coins contain gold or silver, or if they have numismatic value, we'll make you an offer.

A lot of the folks who walk through our door aren't coin collectors. They're regular people who found coins in a relative's belongings and have no idea what they're looking at. That's fine. We'll identify everything, explain what makes certain pieces valuable, and give you a clear number. No jargon, no games.

Here's something worth knowing: U.S. coins minted before 1965 contain 90% silver. That means your old quarters, dimes, and half dollars from the '40s, '50s, and early '60s have real precious metal value. With silver prices strong heading into 2026, even a jar of old coins can add up fast. We weigh them, calculate the silver content, and pay you based on the current market price.

Gold coins are where the big money is right now. A single 1 oz American Gold Eagle is worth over $5,000 at current spot prices. If you have gold coins from any country or era, bring them in. We test purity right in front of you and offer same-day cash payment.

We also handle proof sets, commemorative coins, mint sets still in government packaging, and certified coins in NGC or PCGS slabs. The graded coins are straightforward since the slab tells us the grade. For raw coins, we evaluate condition ourselves and give you our honest assessment.

Stop by our New Brunswick location any weekday from 10 to 6 or Saturday from 10 to 5. You can also request an appraisal online or call (732) 543-1313 with questions.

New Brunswick sees more foreign coins than any of our other locations. Families bring in pieces from the old country, and many of those coins have serious value. British gold sovereigns contain 0.2354 troy ounces of gold. Mexican 50 Pesos contain 1.2057 troy ounces. Even smaller foreign gold coins can be worth hundreds.

Silver foreign coins are common too. Canadian silver dollars minted before 1967 contain 80% silver. Old German marks, French francs, and Australian florins from certain years also carry precious metal content. We know which ones have silver and which ones don't. Bring them all in and we'll sort through everything.

For rare foreign coins, we evaluate collector value separately. Some pieces are worth far more than their metal content due to age, rarity, or historical significance. We pay based on the higher value. That's our standard practice on every coin we buy.

East Brunswick Store Middlesex Store Millstone Store Brick Store Manalapan Store All Locations